You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript. To be a successful McCoy cookie-jar collector, you must be able to identify fakes too. Accept Read More. Copyright 2023 Valuable Antique Detector, Demand and Supply for the McCoy Cookie Jar, How to Identify and Date Authentic Vintage McCoy Cookie Jars, Tips to Spot a Fake Antique McCoy Cookie Jar, Where to Buy or List Vintage McCoy Cookie Jars, Warmans cookie jars: identification and Price Guide, The Ultimate Collectors Encyclopedia of Cookie Jars, 10 Most Valuable Cookie Jars: Value and Price Guide, 15 Most Valuable Vintage Planters Peanut Jars: Collection Guide, Antique Mason Jars: Types, Identification and Value Guide, Atlas Mason Jars Value: A Quick Guide for Collectors, 10 Rarest Mccoy Pottery: Marks and Value Guide, Vintage Rooster Cookie Jar Identification and Value Guide, Antique Cookie Cutters Identification and Value Guide, Treadle Sewing Machine: History, Brands, and Value Guide, Antique German China: History, Brands, and Marks, Antique Flow Blue China: Patterns and Value Guide, Vintage Linens (Identification and Value Guide), Vintage Luggage: Brands, Identification, and Buying Guide, Vintage Libbey Glassware: Identification Valuable Patterns, Vintage Lenox Figurine Identification and Value Guide, Vintage Jadeite Dishes: Complete Fire King Jadeite Price Guide, Vintage Ice Cream Scoop Identification and Value Guide, Vintage Fire King: Identification, Patterns, Types, And Value Guide, Vintage Copper Jello Molds: A History, Styles, and Value Guide.

We also created 2.6 million jobs in the U.S.enough to employ the entire city of Houston, TX! Familiarise yourself with these and other common patterns, so you will immediately walk away when you find a low-priced replica.

However, this article will focus more on McCoy vintage cookie jars. Found something you love but want to make it even more uniquely you? View cart for details. There are so many styles, sizes, colors, shapes, and manufacturers of vintage and modern cookie jars you can choose from depending on your preferred type. The most common jewel used were glass gems, and they added extra sparkle to the jars overall aesthetics. If youre at a loss where to check for these measurements, visit the McCoy Collectors Societywebsite.

No marks are on the bottom of the jar and it has small "chiggers" on the lid and crazing all over the jar. With a long history dating back to the early 20th century, vintage McCoy cookie jars are one of the most sought-after used cookie jars on the market. The other marks include McCoy Made in the USA before 1950.

This page was last updated: 03-Jun 07:30. Shipping policies vary, but many of our sellers offer free shipping when you purchase from them. (15% off), Sale Price $27.20 Original Price $35.00 To assess the condition of McCoy vintage jars, we recommend you check for major scratches, cracks, and chips. There are several knockoffs of this design; however, the original piece was stamped with 207. While many of the items on Etsy are handmade, youll also find craft supplies, digital items, and more. McCoy Lovebirds Cookie Jar might also be called the McCoy Penguin jar. Only a few wound up being produced and those were not used by Quaker Oats, that's when Regal got the contract to produce the Quaker Oats cookie jar. Click Buy it now or Add to cart and proceed to checkout. Does shopping on Etsy help support small businesses?

The truth is that a McCoy cookie jars integral form is incomplete without a lid.

I have been hand carving the pottery lately so it looks really nice. You can also single out a fake McCoy cookie jar by looking at and analyzing its glaze. The tankard is further decorated with a floral spray.". As a collector, you should have an idea of a vintage jars cost price to avoid paying more than the process is worth or underselling one of your McCoy cookie jars. Captcha failed to load. We've sent you an email to confirm your subscription. This type of data sharing may be considered a sale of information under California privacy laws. Several rare cookie jar examples from McCoy pottery sell for hundreds or thousands of dollars, like this McCoy Stagecoach Cookie Jar that sold for $799 in 2023. The astronaut piece is scarce, and $500 is the least price you could get for one of these collectibles. Original Price $30.00 Still, no matter the type or brand of cookie you enjoy today, you can store these sweet treats inside a vintage cookie jar. 66.33, 132.67 When demand is high and supply is low, the vintage McCoy jar is guaranteed to cost more. Turning off the personalized advertising setting wont stop you from seeing Etsy ads or impact Etsy's own personalization technologies, but it may make the ads you see less relevant or more repetitive. The products had simple patterns with engraved or painted strawberries on a white glazed background.

The cute Jack-o-Lantern piece has an orange hue glazed exterior. The majority of the companys most sought-after pottery decorative pieces are cookie jars. Carefully inspect all the edgesround or sharpfor chips. kettle cookie jar with handle, ANTIQUE MCCOY McCOY Mc COY COOKIE JAR (ICE CREAM CHURN / COFFEE GRINDER DESIGN ), Vintage McCoy Pottery Oaken Bucket Cookie Jar With Metal Handle - 7 1/4" Tall, McCOY USA POTTERY WREN BIRD BIRDHOUSE SLANT LID COOKIE JAR Excellent Condition, Vintage 1955 McCoy Pottery Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Halloween Cookie Jar USA, Vintage McCoy Large Cookie Jar, Clown with Lid, 1940s Pottery Original, Vintage McCoy Pottery Cookie Pot Cookie Jar, Vintage MCCOY POTTERY Smiley Face Cookie Jar Have A Happy Day -lid fixed, VTG McCoy USA Smiley Face Cookie Jar Have Happy Day broke lid /crack in jar, Vintage 1960's McCoy Pottery OWL Ceramic Cookie Jar #204 USA, large MCCOY LAMB pottery COOKIE JAR basketweave BROWN stain BEIGE ceramic #127, Vintage McCoy Pottery Koala Bear & Cub Cookie Jar (11 by 8 by 6"), Vintage McCoy Pottery Spirit of '76 Lot Of 5 Pieces National Gallery Art Perfect, Vintage McCoy Pink and Blue Striped Cookie Jar Lancaster colony trademark, VINTAGE MCCOY ART POTTERY TURTLE COOKIE JAR BUTTERFLY BROWN CERAMIC STONEWARE, Vintage 70s McCoy Pottery Flower Power Black W/ Flowers Cookie Jar Mid Century, Vintage McCoy Kookie Kettle Cookie Jar USA Pottery Tea Pot Wire Handle 1960's, Vintage Nelson McCoy Pottery Burlap Bag Cookie Jar, Leave feedback about your eBay search experience - opens in new window or tab. The shape of the cookie jar is another medium to estimate its age. It is one of McCoys rarest pieces. The Roseville, Ohio-based Nelson McCoy Sanitary Stoneware company, founded in 1848, mainly produced decorative and functional stoneware items like jugs, pitchers, crocs, and of course, cookie jars. There is no general value for all the McCoy cookie jars in existence today.

(15% off), Sale Price 48.09 *BEAUTIFUL* VintageMcCoy KEEBLER ELF Tree House COOKIE Jarw/ Lid USA #350!! No one knows how many of these jars exist. Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

A jar without a lid or with a broken lid has its value significantly reduced. In some decades, at least two marks were used. Is it a huge cookie jar or a giant decorative ornament? Therefore, if you come across a low-priced authentic McCoy cookie jar, theres a high probability that it is in bad condition. Original Price 41.56 222 Vintage Rare, Rare Vintage McCoy Pottery Beagle Dog Cookie Jar, VINTAGE 1968 McCoy Time for Cookies Mouse on a Clock Cookie Jar 14, Vintage McCoy Pottery Cookie House Cookie Jar, McCOY VINTAGE PILLSBURY DOUGHBOY BOBBY BAKER COOKIE JAR, Vintage McCoy ?? Cookie jars were created for the sole purpose of storing delicious and aromatic cookies for a long time. The Nelson McCoy Sanitary Stoneware Company was founded in 1910. Vintage Keebler Elf Treehouse Cookie Jar McCoy #350 1980s NEW, Vintage McCOY Brown Thinking Hound Dog Cookie Jar #0272 - Broken Lid, Vintage McCoy 263 Red Strawberry w/ Green Stem Lid Pottery Cookie Jar, Vintage McCoy Brush Pink Kitten Cookie Jar Cat Great Condition K26 USA, Vintage 1950 McCoy I Wish I Had A Cookie Cookie Jar Whishing Well, Vintage McCoy Two-Faced Yellow Duck In Basket Cookie Jar 19750s USA, Vintage W.C. Fields McCoy Cookie Jar 153 USA, Vintage Brush McCoy HUMPTY DUMPTY Pottery Cookie Jar, W-29, Vintage McCoy Fruit Picnic Basket Cookie Jar Marked USA 1960's, Vintage McCoy Cookie Jar Red Tomatoes in a Yellow Basket 0274 Ceramic, Vintage - 1961 McCoy Pottery "Cookie Express" Caboose Cookie Jar, Vintage McCoy Cookie Jar Leaves Grapes Nuts, ** Vtg AMERICAN BISQUE/McCoy Pottery COOKIES Out of This World" Cookie Jar **, McCoy Blushing Yellow Apple Cookie Jar Ceramic Vintage MCM, McCoy Picnic Basket Cookie Jar with Fruit - Vintage 1962-63 USA, Keebler Elf Tree Cookie Jar With Lid Ceramic Ernie Sign Vintage 1981 McCoy 10", Vintage Ceramic Pillsbury Dough Boy Cookie Jar McCoy USA, Vintage McCoy USA Pottery Pineapple Cookie Jar, AMERICAN BISQUE McCoy Pottery Out of This World Cookie Jar Space Ship Astronaut, 2 8 Vintage 1970's McCoy Pottery Strawberry Pattern Cookie Canister Jar Lid SN, Vintage Brush McCoy Cookie Jar COW WITH WINKING CAT Sitting on Back USA, Vintage McCoy Thinking Dog Cookie Jar 0272 Canister USA Pottery Retro Hound, Vintage Sleeping Bear And Honey Bee Cookie Jar Mccoy 143 Made in USA 9x8, Vintage 1970's McCoy Pottery Strawberry Pattern Cookie Canister Jar Lid 8" SN, Vintage/Antique 1940's McCoy Rocking Horse a Cookie Jar G221, INDIAN BUST CHIEF PONTIAC by Mc COY COLLECTOR COOKIE JAR SIGNED VINTAGE, Vintage McCoy White Cookie Bear Cookie Jar 1940's, Vintage McCoy Mac Dog Cookie Jar #208 1967-68 Rare Collectible Beautiful, Vintage McCoy Bell Pepper Cookie Jar W/ Lid # 157, Vintage McCoy MCM Tommy Turtle Cookie Jar #271 W/Butterfly Lid, McCoy Liberty Bell Bronze Metallic Cookie Jar Vintage Collectible Made in USA, Vtg McCoy "Thinking Dog" Brown Hound Dog #0272 Cookie Treat Jar USA, Vintage Mccoy Red Strawberry Cookie Jar No.263 Iconic Midcentury Pottery Art, C. 1973 Rare McCoy Uncle Sam's Hat Cookie Jar Vintage Made In USA, Vintage McCoy Kookie Kettle Cookie Jar USA w Metal Handle 1960's, Vintage McCoy Cookie Jar Covered Wagon Tan Yellow Brown 1960's, Vintage Retro McCoy Pottery Red Strawberry Cookie Jar with Lid VGC Great Detail. With the right match, a cookie jar can be restored to its original value. The jar is green, but when looking at the mark and paper tag, the factory called it slate blue. Its estimated production date is unknown because it has an uncharacteristic orange-red glaze with a height of 10.5 inches. Because most Freddy the Gleep jars in the market are fakes.

From time immemorial, parents and housekeepers have understood that these fragrant and delicious edibles must be displayed so the family and visitors can see them. Pre-Owned. Before you purchase any Fred the Gleep cookie jar by McCoy, ensure you check for authenticity. She has contributed to Antique Trader, Todays Vintage, and more. It was finally authenticated when a 1965 McCoy catalog surfaced. Turning off personalized advertising opts you out of these sales. Learn more in our Privacy Policy., Help Center, and Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy. Dan Beem has owned this jar since 1977 - when it was discovered it in the basement of a house he bought. When the jar was found the maker was unknownbut thought to be a real McCoy. You decide. The solid color McCoy clown rare is indeed a very rare jar. The phrase good as gold is used by collectors to describe elegant vintage cookie jars in perfect condition.

Original Price 148.42 However, you may be lucky to find replacement lids on online marketplaces like Etsy and eBay, or you could attend auctions or estate sales to check for a close replacement. Dozens of cookie jar designs were manufactured until the early 1990s when the company shut down. Fake McCoy designs are usually smaller or shorter in size than the original items. McCoy Cookie jars are iconic in the collectible industry. Public collections can be seen by the public, including other shoppers, and may show up in recommendations and other places. If you have a set or manage to find one that was produced in the 1930s or before the mid-1990s, their market value may be higher than similar products released in the other half of the century. Why bury your cookies with other food items in the cupboard or pantry when you can keep them fresh and flavorful in a cookie jar. There was a problem subscribing you to this newsletter. (20% off), Sale Price 66.33 The makers mark is a crucial feature of every vintage item.

To enable personalized advertising (like interest-based ads), we may share your data with our marketing and advertising partners using cookies and other technologies. Over the years, the purpose of cookie jars has expanded to being a case for hiding money, something like a piggy bank. About the Cookie Jar Line. ALL RIGHT RESERVED. The Coalby Cat is all black, with cold-painted features, including gold trim on the paws and whiskers. Our global marketplace is a vibrant community of real people connecting over special goods.

Etsys 100% renewable electricity commitment includes the electricity used by the data centers that host Etsy.com, the Sell on Etsy app, and the Etsy app, as well as the electricity that powers Etsys global offices and employees working remotely from home in the US. During this period, the company also created bean-pot-shaped jars with slanted or angled finials. 39.47, 41.56 You can buy or sell your vintage McCoy cookie jars through any of the websites below. Probably due to its shape or design. The jar was produced in white with cold paint decorating, also was produced in a special black glaze, but only two or three of these black jars are known. McCoy made cookie jars for nearly six decades, with nearly everything you can imagine as a subject. Send me exclusive offers, unique gift ideas, and personalized tips for shopping and selling on Etsy. Some of the technologies we use are necessary for critical functions like security and site integrity, account authentication, security and privacy preferences, internal site usage and maintenance data, and to make the site work correctly for browsing and transactions. Wheel thrown pottery is my passion and it relaxes me at the same time. How many times have you seen the word rare or hard-to-find on a description of a cookie jar? The words were changed in 1948 to "Cookies". Here are some of the most valuable McCoy cookie jars. Please. Barbara Crews is a lifelong collector who was featured on A&E for her collections.

The same is known as biscuit jars/tins in the United Kingdom. As a collector, you can learn to date prospective jars by assessing features like design, shape, colors, and makers mark. (50% off), Sale Price 96.47

The cookie jars produced between 1930 through 1943 sported a USA mark with a noticeable abstract line in their background. To know more about the value of McCoy cookie jars, and even other McCoy pottery items, you must assess their age, condition, rarity, provenance, and demand. The easiest way to estimate production date of a McCoy cookie jar is to assess its decoration or design. (21% off), Sale Price $21.00 Those partners may have their own information theyve collected about you. in English and Linguistics. McCoy products released from 1970 to 1990 are widely more available than those released in the 1930s and 40s. She specializes in antiques (mainly Victorian through Mid-Century), antique jewelry, old house renovations, and lifestyle and home-related content.

See each listing for international shipping options and costs. Original Price 165.04 96.47, 148.42 Copyright 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Sale Price 118.73 Original Price 142.44 Some experts believe that fake McCoys are more than the authentic pieces, and we cant help but agree with them. These books can be found in local libraries or bookstores. These pottery items are made using clay mined from Roseville lands. Some companies make cookie jars in designs that McCoy Pottery never made. Of what use is a cookie jar if it has no cap to keep off contaminants and other elements. 2022 HEIRLOOMS AT HOME & AGELESS HEIRLOOMS.

However, others with white, blue, green, yellow, and ivory fire-glazed paints were released in the 1940s and 1950s. View Etsys Privacy Policy. New and used Cookie Jars for sale in Seminole Springs, Florida on Facebook Marketplace. 128.19, 142.44 In 2020 alone, purchases on Etsy generated nearly $4 billion in income for small businesses. Set where you live, what language you speak, and the currency you use. Cookies and similar technologies are used to improve your experience, to do things like: Without these technologies, things like personalized recommendations, your account preferences, or localisation may not work correctly. Fortunately, these reproductions tend to be of lower quality, which makes them easier to spot. It is believed that McCoy made a model for the Quaker Oats jar, but McCoy had trouble with the decals being blurred. Some of the cookie jars had a semicircle moon instead of a line. You can browse the Index, or click here for a page by page look at each cookie jar in order.

Linking up with veteran McCoy collectors gives you a chance to find and gain more knowledge about these pieces. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Original Price $360.00 (10% off), Keep collections to yourself or inspire other shoppers! A jar with good cold paint is hard to find. 140.28, 165.04 Pinterest.com By Barbara Crews Updated on 10/25/17 Founded in 1910 as the Nelson McCoy Sanitary Stoneware Company, the Roseville, Ohio company produced many highly sought-after collectibles, especially their cookie jars, which the company started producing in the 1930s.

$33.25, $35.00

This way, youd be able to feel shallow cracks that arent yet visible. If anything, it would give you a nostalgic reminder of how things were in the mid-1900s. The Nelson pottery company drew inspiration from trending aspects through the different decades of its existence. Beem also worked at McCoy for many years. The Coalby cat cookie jar is a less common McCoy design. Several rare cookie jar examples from McCoy pottery sell for hundreds or thousands of dollars, like this McCoy Stagecoach Cookie Jar that sold for $799 in 2023. Some vintage cookie jars have become worthless due to their lack of a cover.

New Listing Vintage McCoy Pottery Cookie Jar Canister Light Pink and Blue Stripes #131 USA. When a jar is as rare as this one, values are hard to pin down, therefore the online auction price is shown. You could also do this for the inner rims. Check for the measurements of an authentic McCoy piece, and compare them with the measurements of the reproduced piece. Welcome to the McCoy Pottery Online's Cookie Jar Index. Etsy is powered by 100% renewable electricity. If you need more information about cookie jars, you can consult books on antique cookie jars or join a McCoy online forum. However, collectors claim this design debuted in this decade. They would be able to provide more insight on the accurate decade your McCoy jar was produced. Pieces owned and passed down by these families will continue to be values higher than the McCoy cookie jars purchased by less-reputable or common names. $284.40, $360.00 During its active years, it was rebranded a couple of times due to the interests of its stockholders at the time. Etsy uses cookies and similar technologies to give you a better experience, enabling things like: Detailed information can be found in Etsys Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy and our Privacy Policy. Eventually, these McCoy cookie jars are sold off at average prices or less.

In addition to this, ensure the cookie jars lid is perfect.

Before the company started producing cookie jars, many utilitarian product designs featured swirl stone-like glazes. There are several McCoy cookie jar reproductions on the market. Something went wrong. From The Collector's Encyclopedia of McCoy Pottery by Huxford: "White-Stone Bristol glaze (ivory) shaded top and bottom with blue in a basketweave design. Youll see ad results based on factors like relevancy, and the amount sellers pay per click. Bottles, bowls, mugs, vases I like making them all . Boasting an array of quirky and timeless styles, each McCoy piece brings a unique character and a touch of nostalgia to your kitchen. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Original Price 53.43 Circular flat finials followed these in the mid-1930s.


You can browse the Index, or click here for a page by page look at each cookie jar in order.

Original Price $32.00 Mammy #2 originally had the words "Dem Cookies show am good" on the front of the dress on the jars made from 1944 through 1947. Absolutely! Read our Cookie Policy. Lauren Thomann is an antique dealer, freelance writer, and editor with 16 years of experience and a B.A. This type of data sharing may be considered a sale of information under California privacy laws. The jar was for sale at the price of $7,500 through the Ohio Ceramic Center. We cant help but mention the Strawberry design era. McCoy Cookie jars have the company mark at the bottom. Try contacting them via Messages to find out!

In fact, it remained a giant pottery corporation until its closure. Ornament or Cookie Jar? Every market is governed by supply and demand basis. It is easy to get fooled by an unscrupulous McCoy collector as these variations are subtle. The company manufactured various pottery pieces out of their facility in Roseville, Ohio, but they didnt start producing cookie jars until the 1930s. 118.73, 148.42 Something went wrong. Try using a different browser or disabling ad blockers. It is worth mentioning that it is possible to have a rare piece that isnt in demand. Between 1940 and 1944, the cookie jars were in the form of the old milk can and had molded blue, ivory, yellow, green, and black handles. Authors provide information about hundreds of patterns, sizes, and glazes. New and used Cookie Jars for sale in Gandy, Florida on Facebook Marketplace. homeonthe86 (49) 100%. To know youre purchasing the original Coalby cookie jar, confirm the quality of materials used. The following list is comprised of McCoy Cookie Jars dating from the Late 30's to Present day. They are often priced from $50 to hundreds of dollars. We will catalog as many jars as possible here for you, As a community, we will achieve the impossble.

However, it is not as important for McCoys pottery items, as the company did not mark everyone. Reading guidebooks is honestly the best way to learn how to single out fake pottery items. The Roseville, Ohio-based Nelson McCoy Sanitary Stoneware company, founded in 1848, mainly produced decorative and functional stoneware items like jugs, pitchers, crocs, and of course, cookie jars. In 1933, the company rebranded to Nelson McCoy Pottery Co. McCoy vintage cookie jars were first produced by McCoy, a pottery brand, in the 1930s. Youll see ad results based on factors like relevancy, and the amount sellers pay per click. This will differ depending on what options are available for the item. Find great deals and sell your items for free. Each has its individual value that is determined by some factors. With these, youd know how much other similar vintage McCoy cookie jars could fetch today. Reproduction Alert There are several McCoy cookie jar reproductions on the market. This vintage McCoy piece was released in time to celebrate Halloween in 1955. Dont see this option? Original Price $150.00   United States   |   English (US)   |   $ (USD). If your McCoy cookie jar has earth-toned fire-glazed paint, it was likely manufactured in the 1930s.

The McCoy stoneware company was active till late 1900.
The seller might still be able to personalize your item. You are unlikely to view any top ten valuable cookie jars without coming across at least four McCoy products.